One class of 6th grade students doing a robot building project led by technology educators Angelo Carideo and David Liotta at IS 62, Ditmas (a Brooklyn middle school) took a written survey and then engaged in an important conversation about the life lessons they learned through robot building. Here are some of the high points:
Frustrations can boil over. One student described how he got to the point of thinking “about breaking the robot” because its color sensor did not function. Sometimes kit pieces didn’t fit. Several students described intense frustrations when their robot failed to perform. Getting the robot’s program to result in making a full turn was a task that pushed them to the limit.Prompted, students connected “missing pieces” in robot building to other instances of missing pieces in life. Students in search of birth parents saw this as a “missing pieces” investigation to find life truths that eluded them.
How had they “fixed” issues or problems to successfully build a functioning robot? Those groups who were frustrated by the loss of crucial kit pieces came up with the idea of organizing and inventorying pieces. This allowed them to keep track of the pieces more effectively. One student noted that successful programming required reviewing all the programming possibilities. She undertook that task with another team member to find a series of commands that would work for their robot. One student became the scheduler/organizer who assigned turns at building or programming. Another girl took responsibility for faulty programming and finally got it right. She was “really happy” when it worked. Another team used the manual to get its robot wiring right. Some teams simply went forward without a pivotal ball and a front bumper, revamping their design to take advantage of parts that were available.
Actual Applications to a real life, career or job challenge? Inventorying items turned out to be a job that one student’s uncle had at a local 99 cent store. Another student recalled a hardware store clerk who had a written inventory of screw types available with a back order list. Scheduling was familiar to students because they worked in a dean’s or principal’s office. They mentioned a scheduled line-up for access to computers in the library. Students mentioned their own multitasking parents, teachers, and coaches who got tasks done on time, whether or not others helped. Some felt that this ability was necessary in real life to success.
They reflected on what, in real life, got done, but not exactly how it was planned or expected? This question took a while getting a response. A student artist noted that a mural he worked on in another school came out great, but was not really the design he set out to do. Students detailed how family meals went off without required silverware or china plates and sufficient dish ingredients. Ultimately most students joyously shared their ultimate success in programming the robots successfully in spite of frustrations.
“We basically put in a code, uploaded it to the robot, and the robot did what we told it to do” said one group. Some students basked in their robot’s ability to sense colors. One student was excited by the fact that this small robot had the capacity to react faster than a human. Some students were excited by teamwork: “All of us worked together, we weren’t a team; we were one single person working on a project.” One student found “using my hands to put each piece of the robot in place” was exciting. Another cited the “thrill of creating movements that seemed to come to life . . . I got to be in complete control of something… my robot… the robot’s name was Toby…I had to be careful with Toby because he was very fragile… without my group [he] would never have been created… that’s the best feeling in the world.”
From concept to building to programming, robotics parallels life’s journey of personal, career, and citizen goals. To produce and reflect on a shared effort is a goal that teachers, parents, entrepreneurs, politicians, and leaders share. Robot building models a life process that involves following directions and working together. Talking and writing about it concretizes robot building by underscoring its life lessons.
Director of the Writing Institute
Dr. Reissman designed the survey and facilitated the literacy and life lessons reflections described in this piece